Is Integration Testing Really Necessary?

pierre-bamin-5B0IXL2wAQ0-unsplash (1) (1)

The short answer is yes. For software to work properly, all units should integrate and perform as they’re expected to. To ensure this is the case, you will need to perform integration testing.

Getting features to work together is like introducing your partner to your family – you never know if they’re going to get along at first. Will grandma do her ‘false teeth trick’ the minute you walk in the door? Will dad tell that stupid joke and burn the dinner again? The only way you’re going to find out is by bringing them together and running an ‘integration test’. It’s the same with software applications. But is integration testing really necessary for quality software? The answer is yes, and here’s why.

Integration testing and continuous integration (CI) are different concepts. Integration tests check interactions between components or services. CI is a development practice of integrating changes frequently and using automated checks; an integration test can run in CI without the two terms meaning the same thing.

Why Integration testing is Necessary

To ensure third-party applications and internal modules work seamlessly together within your software, you’ve got to combine them, test the combination, and evaluate the results.

One common example of an integration is the payment gateway for an eCommerce site. The integration between the application under test (AUT) and the payment process at every point where these features exchange data must be carefully tested across the relevant successful and failure scenarios. The test cases for this would include (but are not limited to):

  • Normal checkout with success
  • Normal checkout and user cancelled
  • Normal checkout and cart browser closed/connection cut
  • Normal checkout and transaction declined (card expired, unsupported payment type, etc.)

Other examples include accessing and using third-party APIs, web services, plugins, and anything else your developers did not create themselves.

NOTE: Integration testing can sometimes be confused with end-to-end testing, so you can check out this OnPath blog post where we compare the two and clear that up.

These checks also apply to interfaces between your own services or modules, not just third-party products. State which boundary the test covers and whether dependencies are real, sandboxed or simulated. For a worked comparison, see integration versus end-to-end testing.

Automation Testing: Are You Ready to Start

Evaluate your automation readiness with Are You Ready to Start? — a practical guide to avoiding common pitfalls, scaling smart, and making automation work for your team.

Benefits of Integration testing

Integration tests help expose failures that isolated component tests cannot: mismatched data formats, missing authentication, incorrect state changes and unexpected dependency responses.

  • Verify that information crosses a named interface in the required format.
  • Exercise success, rejection, timeout and retry behavior.
  • Check the resulting service or data state, not just that a request returned.
  • Retain repeatable checks at important connection points as the product changes.

For example, a payment adapter may accept a request while the order service stores the wrong payment reference. A focused integration test can check both sides without driving a full browser journey.

Integration testing Best Practices

Plan integration checks around the interfaces and risks in your application.

  1. Map the boundary. List the components, protocol, data and expected outcomes.
  2. Control the setup. Use synthetic records and appropriate sandboxes or test doubles. Document what the test does not exercise.
  3. Test more than a successful response. Include invalid data, rejected authorization, unavailable dependencies and retries where relevant.
  4. Verify business effects. Check the required state through supported test APIs or read-only assertions in the test environment.
  5. Keep failures diagnosable. Record the build, environment and relevant request/state evidence without credentials or personal data.

Run checks when the relevant interfaces become available. Automated integration tests can join unit and other checks in a CI pipeline; a manual integration test is still integration testing. Avoid making the entire external dependency chain mandatory for every focused check.

Long Story Short

“Testers don’t like to break things; they like to dispel the illusion that things work.” — Kaner, Bach, Pettichord

Quality assurance testing is done to ensure the end-user experience is seamless. When your software application combines different modules and third-party apps that need to work together for the application to function as expected, integration testing is necessary. And yes, is integration testing really necessary for quality software? Absolutely.

Want to learn more about different types of software testing? Check out the OnPath blog. And, if you’d like to talk to a specialist to see how we can help, reach out to us.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

What is integration testing?

Integration testing checks how selected components or services interact, including data exchange, error handling and resulting state. The boundary may be between internal modules, an application and its database, or your service and an external provider.

What are the main benefits of integration testing?

Benefits include reliable user experiences, regression testing at key integration points, and early detection of potential conflicts.

How is CI different from automated integration testing?

Continuous integration is the practice of integrating changes frequently and checking them with automated builds and tests. Integration testing is a kind of testing focused on component or service interactions. CI can run unit, integration and other checks; automating a test does not make it an integration test.

When should integration checks be performed?

Begin when the relevant components and interfaces are available. Keep checks repeatable as those interfaces change, and run suitable automated checks in CI. Do not wait until a complete end-to-end application exists to check an important boundary.

Is integration testing necessary for third-party API integrations?

Yes. Check the expected requests, responses and failure handling using appropriate provider sandboxes or test doubles. Include authentication errors, unavailable services and retries when those risks apply; record which external connections were actually exercised.

Can integration testing improve end-user satisfaction?

It can reveal failures between services that would otherwise interrupt a customer journey. Combine focused integration checks with selected end-to-end journeys and other testing appropriate to the product’s risks.

Logo Colour

Sign up to receive notifications when we post our next article, and stay OnPath with good QA practices.

Written by

Picture of Brian Borg
Brian Borg
Over the years, Brian has moved from web developer (bug creator) to QA lead (bug finder) to consultant and entrepreneur. He’s enjoyed leading test efforts for diverse projects and now explores the shifting landscape of AI and test intelligence as it applies to QA. When not working with the OnPath team of dedicated engineers, you’ll find Brian enjoying his dual backyards of the Colorado Rockies and the Indian Himalayas.
Picture of Brian Borg
Brian Borg
Over the years, Brian has moved from web developer (bug creator) to QA lead (bug finder) to consultant and entrepreneur. He’s enjoyed leading test efforts for diverse projects and now explores the shifting landscape of AI and test intelligence as it applies to QA. When not working with the OnPath team of dedicated engineers, you’ll find Brian enjoying his dual backyards of the Colorado Rockies and the Indian Himalayas.

Related content

hands-testing-ui-images-on-ipad-with-laptop-in-the-background

Integration Testing vs End-to-End Testing: What’s the Difference?

The terms end-to-end testing and integration testing often create confusion in the software testing world. While both approaches aim to improve application quality, they...

API Testing for Agile Delivery: A Practical Step-by-Step Guide

Learn API testing step by step: validate business values, test authorization and failure cases, choose tools, and build useful checks into agile CI/CD....

Automation Testing Frameworks: Pyramids, Tools, and Modern Choices

Build an automation testing framework that connects unit, API, and UI coverage with tool choices, maintainable CI checks, and reviewed AI assistance....
Logo Colour

Get notified when we post our next article!